Saturday, June 18, 2016

Krugman: When Virtue Fails [feedly]


Another Krugman strawman -- "Southern Europeans are lazy" -- is shot down. But what about his favored -- economically sound -- alternative: hand over your country's fiscal -- governing -- powers to a United States of Europe? Duh. The only ones pushing that were the left wing of Syriza --- too much like Bernie for Krugman. Another perfectly rational position in the abstract that has all the political legs of a decade old fruit basket

When Virtue Fails
http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/06/17/when-virtue-fails/

There are two narratives about the euro crisis. One – favored by English-speaking economists, including yours truly – sees it all through the lens of optimum currency area theory. Basically, shocks happen, and when you establish a common currency without a shared government, you give countries no good way, fiscal or monetary, to respond to these shocks.

The other narrative, however, favored by Berlin and Brussels, sees the whole thing as the wages of sin. Southern European countries behaved irresponsibly, and now they're paying the price. What everyone needs to do, they say, is institute a reign of virtue, of fiscal responsibility with structural reform, and all will be well.

So it's important to note that the euro area's locus of trouble is moving from the south to an arc of northern discomfort — to countries that don't at all fit the stereotype of lazy southerners.

Notably, Finland is the new sick man of Europe. And theNetherlands — which in many ways is more German than the Germans — is doing slightly better than Italy but significantly worse than France and Portugal.

Indeed, France – the subject of a thousand news reports about how a generous welfare state is killing its economy — is doing relatively OK.

The specific shocks vary. Finland has been hit by the fall of Nokia and the adverse effect of digital media on newsprint exports. The Dutch are suffering from a burst housing bubble, severe deleveraging, and an extra burden of austerity mania. But the overall point is that when things go wrong there's no good answer.

So maybe the woes of the euro reflect a bad system, not moral failure on the part of troubled nations? Das ist unmöglich!


 -- via my feedly newsfeed

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.